top of page

Young Adults Struggle More With Uncertainty Than in the 1990s, Study Finds

17 hours ago
6 min read

Young adults in the United States and Canada are less able to tolerate uncertainty than college students were in the 1990s. That is the finding of a meta-analysis published November 18 in JAMA Psychiatry. The trait rose about three times as fast after 2012, around when smartphones became common. Researchers say it may help explain rising anxiety.


  • The study pooled more than 130 earlier studies covering more than 35,000 college students.

  • Intolerance of uncertainty rose steadily among students from 1992 to 2023.

  • From 2012 to 2023, scores rose about three times as fast as from 1992 to 2011.

  • Researchers at Boston University and Columbia University led the work.

  • The authors list smartphones, social media, loneliness and the pandemic as possible factors, not proven causes.


Cover reading Living With Not Knowing, with a young adult on a dorm bed at night lit by a smartphone

A study tracked three decades of college students


College-aged young adults have grown steadily more uncomfortable with the unknown over the past 30 years, researchers found. The study was published November 18 in JAMA Psychiatry. The first author is Jeroen van Baar, a postdoctoral associate at the Boston University School of Public Health.


The senior author is Katherine Keyes, a professor of epidemiology at Columbia University's Mailman School of Public Health. Coauthors came from the University of Regina in Canada and the National University of Singapore.


A previous review had found rising scores among college students from 1992 to 2014. The new study extends that record by almost a decade, through 2023.


The team gathered peer-reviewed studies of undergraduates in the United States and Canada who completed a standard questionnaire called the Intolerance of Uncertainty Scale. Together with the earlier review, the final sample covered more than 130 studies and more than 35,000 students. The typical student was about 20 years old, and most were women.


Keyes summed up the work in a statement from Columbia:


"Our results provide updated insights into one of the core building blocks of anxiety: intolerance of uncertainty."

What is intolerance of uncertainty?


Intolerance of uncertainty is difficulty coping when an outcome is unknown or important information is missing. People who score high on it tend to see the unknown as a threat. They may worry more, seek reassurance or avoid making decisions.


For example, someone high in the trait might keep checking an inbox while waiting for a job offer. Someone lower in the trait may still feel some stress, but finds it easier to wait and go about the day.


Psychologists treat the trait as a building block of anxiety, not a diagnosis. Keyes said it is not a health outcome or a root cause of disease. She described it as an intermediary thinking pattern that contributes to anxiety.


The questionnaire comes in a 27-item long form and a 12-item short form. Students rate statements about how they deal with surprises, delays and unclear situations. The higher the score, the less comfortable the person is with uncertainty.


Van Baar explained why the team expected the trait to follow mental health trends:


"If IU plays an important role in anxiety and depression, we would expect it to have increased alongside these conditions."

The rise sped up around 2012


Scores went up across every period the team examined, but the increase accelerated after 2012. On the long-form scale, average scores rose about two-thirds of a point per year from 1992 to 2023. In standard units, the increase from 2012 to 2023 was about three times as fast as from 1992 to 2011.


The timing lines up with other mental health data. Anxiety symptoms have risen among young adults in recent years, according to federal health data, after staying relatively steady through the 1990s and early 2000s.


Around 2012, smartphones also became common among young people. That let them stay plugged into news, group chats and social feeds all day, even during stressful events.


The authors note that their data cannot show what caused the rise. They cite several possible factors: more smartphone and social media use, academic pressure, loneliness, economic instability, childhood adversity and the COVID-19 pandemic. Van Baar said these factors are likely intertwined and reinforce one another.


The study was funded by a grant from the National Institute of Mental Health. The team registered its main hypothesis before collecting data, a step meant to keep researchers from steering results after the fact.


Why tech and phones are part of the story


The findings add to a growing debate about how always-on technology shapes young minds. A nonstop stream of notifications and headlines can make every unresolved problem feel urgent. It can also make it easier to search for answers than to accept not knowing.


Social media also rewards quick reactions. Posts about breaking news, market swings or layoffs can spread quickly, often before the facts are clear.


Some researchers also point to changes in everyday independence. Psychologist Jean Twenge of San Diego State University has suggested that fewer teens now drive, hold paid jobs or go out with friends. Those activities once gave young people practice handling situations without a script.


The debate is already reaching schools. Sparknify reported this week on a Harvard study that found strict school phone bans added weeks of learning. Together, the two studies show how much attention researchers are now paying to daily phone habits.


An American Psychological Association survey earlier this year found that 68% of adults said they had grown used to living with uncertainty. About a third of young adults said they had put off decisions about their future because they felt overwhelmed.


College students studying at a library table with their smartphones stacked face down in a basket

What does this mean for young workers and the companies that hire them?


Rising intolerance of uncertainty could change how a generation learns, works and makes decisions. Young people entering the job market now face fast-changing jobs, new AI tools and a shifting economy. People who find ambiguity distressing may struggle more in that kind of environment.


Workplaces add their own uncertainty. Reorganizations, shifting priorities and hiring freezes are common in tech, and new employees often have the least context about what is coming next.


There is hopeful news in the research. Keyes said effective interventions to reduce intolerance of uncertainty already exist for people with anxiety and mood disorders. The authors suggest that lowering the trait could help curb the rise in anxiety, though they did not test that directly.


Some forms of cognitive behavioral therapy already focus on this skill. They teach people to practice small uncertain situations step by step, so that the unknown feels less threatening over time.


The study also has limits. It covered only college students in the United States and Canada, leaving out young people who did not attend college or who live elsewhere. The data are self-reported, and the analysis shows a trend over time, not a cause.


Van Baar noted another possibility. Greater mental health awareness may make young people more willing to report symptoms in surveys, even if their underlying feelings have not changed as much.


For Silicon Valley, the finding matters in two ways. Tech companies build the phones and apps that the authors flag as possible factors, and they also hire many recent graduates. Managers who give clear expectations, regular feedback and room to learn from mistakes may help new hires handle an uncertain job market.


Five things will show which way this goes.


  1. Follow-up studies that test whether smartphone and social media use drive the rise in intolerance of uncertainty.

  2. Wider use of therapy programs that target intolerance of uncertainty in young adults.

  3. Data on young adults who did not attend college, which this study did not cover.

  4. Results from school phone limits as more districts adopt them.

  5. New federal data on anxiety symptoms among adults under 30.


A generation used to instant answers is finding it harder to live with questions, and researchers are only starting to learn why.


Subscribe to Sparknify for tech news and the people behind it.


Questions & Answers


Q1: My 22-year-old talks through worries with an AI chatbot. Will that help with uncertainty, or make it worse?


This study did not test chatbots, so there is no way to know yet. The authors list smartphone and social media use and loneliness among possible factors behind the rise. Young people are already turning to AI for support, as covered in a Gallup survey on young people and AI companions.


Q2: Do outages and tech glitches add to that sense of uncertainty?


The study did not measure outages, but disruptions at banks, airlines and other services add to a feeling that things are less reliable. Companies are responding by planning for failures, as covered in why CIOs are rebuilding their backup plans.


Q3: As a parent in Silicon Valley, how can I help my kids get more comfortable with not knowing the answer?


The study did not test fixes, but researchers note that teens now have fewer chances to handle new situations on their own. Hands-on projects let kids try, fail and try again, as in a hands-on drone workshop in Menlo Park for grades 4 to 8.

Comments


Upcoming Events

No events at the moment

More Articles

Subscribe to Latest Sparknify News and Event Notifications

Current Role
bottom of page