New York's Six-Ounce Levain Cookie Is Coming to San Jose's Santana Row

Until now, the only way to taste New York's most famous cookie in Silicon Valley was to put in an online order or get on a plane. That is set to change. Levain Bakery, the Upper West Side shop whose six-ounce chocolate chip walnut cookie has long been a rite of passage for tourists, is putting down roots in Northern California. Its first shop in the region is slated for Santana Row in San Jose, with summer 2027 as the target date. In an area used to measuring things by lines and launches, this one comes with butter, walnuts and three decades of history behind it.

What is coming to Santana Row, and when

Bakery representatives made the announcement this week and have put the opening at summer 2027. The new shop will occupy part of a storefront once held by the clothing retailer Chico's, on Santana Row's open-air promenade of shops, restaurants and apartments along Stevens Creek Boulevard.

The menu's main attraction is the Chocolate Chip Walnut, a thick six-ounce round with a craggy top, a soft center and crisp edges. Levain also bakes Dark Chocolate Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Caramel Coconut Chocolate Chip and Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip cookies. There is a vegan and gluten free version of the signature cookie as well, plus rotating flavors like Raspberry Pistachio and Fall Spiced Chocolate Chunk. All of it is baked in house daily.

As for hours and prices in San Jose, nothing has been announced yet. But if the four Southern California shops are any indication, the doors should be open from 7 or 8 in the morning to 10 or 11 at night, and a cookie will run just over $6. The Levain locations page lists those shops in Larchmont Village, Venice, Beverly Hills and Newport Beach.

One thing to know before the grand opening: "On opening day, our new bakeries donate all proceeds to a local charity organization," the company states on its website. Each shop also donates its unsold baked goods at the end of every day.

A cookie that started as training fuel

Levain was never meant to be a cookie company in the first place. Its origins lie with friends and professional bakers Pam Weekes and Connie McDonald, who supplied bread to New York restaurants. In 1995 they took the next step and opened a modest bread shop on West 74th Street, calling it Levain after the French word for leavened bread.

The cookie was an afterthought of sorts. The two founders were training for triathlons and made an extra large chocolate chip walnut cookie to keep their energy up. "As for the cookie? That was a happy accident," the company writes in its founding story. "A sample batch flew off the bakery shelves, and an icon was born."

Word of mouth did the rest over the following decades. Mail order cookies arrived in 1998 and a seasonal shop in the Hamptons in 2000. The bakery has since put down roots in a number of New York neighborhoods, from Harlem to the Upper East Side, NoHo, Williamsburg and Flatiron. Television food shows and travel lists made the original shop on West 74th Street a must for visitors, while social media had its say, with videos of the cookie being torn open to reveal a molten center becoming a genre of their own.

How a neighborhood bakery became a national brand

For most of its history, Levain was content to grow at its own pace and with its own funds. Then, in 2018, the founders brought in Stripes, a New York growth equity firm with an eye on consumer brands, as a partner. That backing helped the company make its move out of New York.

Georgetown in Washington, D.C., got the first location outside the city in 2020. Larchmont Village in Los Angeles came in 2023, and there are now four shops in Southern California, including Venice, Beverly Hills and Newport Beach. All told, the company lists more than 20 locations in New York, California, Illinois, Massachusetts, Pennsylvania, Maryland and Washington, D.C., with one in Miami's Coconut Grove marked as coming soon and San Jose to follow.

Some growth experiments have not lasted. For a time Levain sold smaller frozen cookies in supermarkets across the country, including Whole Foods, but called it quits in 2022, citing rising costs. The brand seems to work best fresh and in person, even if that makes it a bit hard to come by. The company still ships nationwide, but the bakeries are what carry the brand.

Why Santana Row fits the playbook

Look at the spots where Levain has put down roots and a pattern is evident. Larchmont Boulevard in Los Angeles, Abbot Kinney in Venice, Newbury Street in Boston, Bethesda Row in Maryland and Rittenhouse Square in Philadelphia are all of a piece: walkable, well-heeled shopping streets where people stroll, linger and spend. Santana Row was built to be just that kind of place, and it has made itself into one of the South Bay's busiest dining destinations.

The district's current dining lineup is something of a dessert crawl in itself. Johnny Doughnuts, Smitten Ice Cream, Bacio di Latte gelato, Boba Guys and Blue Bottle Coffee sit alongside sit-down restaurants like Dumpling Time, Fogo de Chão and Ozumo. Flora, a California inspired restaurant from a team of local restaurateurs, is coming as well. A cookie shop known for its lines is right at home in a place made for evening wandering.

There is a subtler change at work too. A bakery is taking the place of a clothing store. You can order a blouse on a phone from nearly any shop these days, but a warm cookie fresh from the oven means you have to be there, and open-air centers like Santana Row are keen to have more tenants like that.

What a six-ounce cookie says about building something that lasts

To a reader in Silicon Valley, the Levain story has a ring of familiarity. The breakout product was happenstance: the founders made something for their own use and saw that others wanted it as well. They held off on scaling until the core product and the customer experience were in order, and only then took outside capital to move into markets where shipping and social media had already created demand.

It is a discipline not every startup can muster. After three decades, the signature cookie is little changed. New flavors come and go, but what keeps people in line is the same as it was in the 1990s. In a part of the country that is always shipping new versions, that sort of consistency is a moat in its own right.

Will a New York cookie line form on Santana Row in 2027?

Crowds look likely, at least at first. Levain openings in other cities have drawn lines, and the Bay Area has an audience ready to go, from New York transplants to visitors who have come to know the brand on trips east or through their feeds. For Santana Row, a destination bakery that stays open late is a reason to come back after dinner, and it puts more feet in front of the shops next door. It could also prompt nearby centers, starting with Westfield Valley Fair across Stevens Creek Boulevard, to try to land destination food brands of their own. For the region, it is another sign that national food brands now see Silicon Valley as a market they cannot do without, rather than an afterthought behind San Francisco.

Then there are the questions of cost and staying power. At just over $6 apiece, a cookie is a treat and not something most people buy every day, and the Bay Area's high rents and labor costs will not make running a bakery any cheaper. Novelty wears off, too. The company's 2022 exit from supermarket freezers is a reminder that not every expansion succeeds. Timelines are a risk in themselves: a summer 2027 opening is only a target, and build outs in older retail spaces tend to slip.

The local debate is a familiar one. Some residents and small business owners argue that national chains crowd out independent bakeries, give every shopping district the same look and push rents up to what deep-pocketed brands can pay. Supporters counter that destination brands bring in people who then spend at the independents around them, and that Levain began as a two-person neighborhood shop whose practice of donating opening day proceeds and unsold goods ties each bakery to its community. Both can be right, which makes the hiring and local partners for this opening all the more important.

What to watch: a confirmed opening date and the exact storefront, job postings for bakers and managers in San Jose, menu prices once they are posted, the local charity that receives the opening day proceeds, and whether Levain names a second Northern California location in San Francisco, the Peninsula or the East Bay. Watch, too, whether more New York and Los Angeles food brands make their way to the South Bay.

Until the doors open, Bay Area fans can order online or have cookies delivered, though that is where the price of a cookie gets more complicated. Earlier this week, Sparknify looked at how Olo's new app drops the menu markups hidden in delivery orders, worth a read for anyone who has noticed the same item costing more on an app than at the counter.

Silicon Valley has waited 30 years for this cookie, and it now has about nine months to decide how long a line it is willing to stand in.

Subscribe to Sparknify for Silicon Valley tech news and the people behind it.